Benjamin completed this essay, sometimes called "On the Concept of History," in the spring of However, it wasn't published until , a decade after Benjamin's death. The essay is divided into 20 extremely brief sections. Benjamin begins the essay with an extended analogy in Section 1 · “Theses on the Philosophy of History” Walter Benjamin completed this remarkable eleven-page writing in the spring of , the last year of his life Title: blogger.com Author: scan Created Date: 12/22/ PM
Theses on the Philosophy of History - Wikipedia
German-Jewish intellectuals, the alienated hommes de lettres of early twentieth century German-speaking Central Europe, constituted a class within that complex and multi-layered Jewish society against which a few of them rebelled, a rebellion which however could not prevent the dark disaster awaiting them in the German madness of the s and 40s.
Walter Benjamin was one of those rebels. As in any story of an intellectual figure like Benjamin, there are numerous variants and interpretations of his message. I am not a Benjamin specialist. So in these few pages I am reporting what I have found stimulating and central to this man, who did not become widely known until some twenty years after his death in Today he is a cult figure.
Considerations that most German-Jewish intellectuals of the early s faced, though indecisively, as Arendt goes on to show. Walter Benjamin was a German-Jewish intellectual. He was one of walter benjamin theses on history handful of hommes de lettres as Arendt defines him: people who lived in the world of books but were not obliged to write them for a living, thus alienated from both state and society of those times. He lived in Berlin and Paris, and killed himself in the mountains between France and Spain trying to escape the Nazis and get to America.
You might also think of Benjamin in relation to chance. He had an up and down relationship with both good and bad chance. Mostly the latter. And it killed him. Killed him because he was also a self-defined bungler.
Although Benjamin called himself a literary critic, he was concerned with the truth content of a literary work and left its subject matter for the commentators. But, walter benjamin theses on history to his nature, walter benjamin theses on history, he was much more than a literary critic.
He wrote studious works but was not a scholar. He was a Marxist but never joined the Communist Party. For some twenty years he considered emigration to Palestine but never did. He was not a translator but did magnificent translations into German of Baudelaire and Proust. He was not a poet but he wrote poetically. BUT, being a bungler made him a pushover for the god Chance whose fickleness in his regard made him an even greater bungler.
Calamities happened to him time and again. Bad luck often visited him, as Arendt recalls, personified in German fairytales as a little hunchback. Like when a publisher finally accepted one of his major books, the publishing house promptly folded, walter benjamin theses on history. The little hunchback had intervened. Again, Benjamin escaped Nazi Germany and settled in his beloved Paris. Walter benjamin theses on history when the Nazis were about to bomb Paris he fled to Meaux, East of Paris— toward the Germans he was escaping from.
For his safety, he thought. Bungled again. The little hunchback had visited him. His whole life went like that. Then he bungled right up to the end and he paid the god Bad Chance with his life. Benjamin had obtained an emergency U.
visa from a consulate in unoccupied France, had a Spanish transit visa for Portugal and had walter benjamin theses on history ship passage to the USA. This was not a great problem since you could easily walk over a mountain path from France to Port Bou in Spain and then travel on to Lisbon.
But on that one day—not the day before or the day after—Spain rejected his transit visa. In desperation because of a heart condition, again bungling and with the god Bad Chance and the little hunchback against him, he decided to end it all then and there. His death prompted his friend, the poet Bertold Brecht, also in exile, in Denmark, to remark that this was the first real loss Hitler had caused to German literature.
At the beginning of her introduction, Hannah Arendt notes that posthumous fame seems to be the lot of unclassifiable writers, which Benjamin clearly was. Everything he wrote, she says, was sui generis, in the same way that Kafka was unique. Neither fit into the existing order, nor did they introduce a new genre for future writers. Goldstein believed the problem insoluble, walter benjamin theses on history. Yet, his aim was to force them to admit their Jewishness or be baptized, walter benjamin theses on history, even though he and other Jewish intellectuals realized that would solve nothing.
For German hate was genuine. Benjamin and Kafka fought against the attitude of official middle class Jewry with whom intellectuals like themselves hardly had contact: their lying denial of the very existence of widespread anti-Semitism.
Arendt wrote in that it is hard to take these problems seriously today since it is easy to misinterpret them as mere reaction to the anti-Semitic environment of that era. But not for walter benjamin theses on history of the stature of Benjamin and Kafka. They were not criticizing anti-Semitism as such, but that Jewish middle class for their denial of the existence of anti-Semitism, as well as their the middle class Jews isolation deriving from their loss of reality which was backed up by the wealth of those same classes.
And then their blaming of the Ostjuden Jews from Eastern Europe for any anti-Semitism. Important was that very few German-Jewish writers saw the problem as did Benjamin and Kafka because most of them belonged to that same middle class. Both were escape routes from illusion into reality, from mendacity and self-deception to an honest existence.
For example, there are roughly only kibbutzim left, with about two percent of the population. For those German-Jewish rebels it was as if the solution to their problem was to be found in either Moscow or Jerusalem; however, Benjamin—like Kafka—knew all the time that his productive life was in Europe. Therefore Marxism and the Communist revolutionary movement walter benjamin theses on history him because it opposed the totality of political and spiritual traditions.
One is left to wonder if they had really resolved the insoluble Jewish problem of last century before the tragedy: in any case, they retain their Jewish identity within their own nation-state, Israel, artificial as it may be. In a sense then Benjamin decided not to decide. However, his point of departure always seemed to be the utter destructive basis of Fascism.
His search in Zionism finally discarded before he entered its labyrinth and in Communism which he never adopted, perhaps because of the growing bureaucracy he saw in Communist Russia when he went to Moscow in and which might have reminded him of the official Jewry he was escaping from.
His search for alternatives shines through in his memorable Theses on the Philosophy of History. Walter Benjamin completed this remarkable eleven-page writing in the walter benjamin theses on history ofthe last year of his life.
It was first published in Neue Rundschau in Berlin, a quarterly magazine founded in and which has existed well over one hundred years, publishing the best of European writing, essays and fiction, by authors such as Rainer Maria Rilke, Thomas Mann and Franz Kafka. Hannah Arendt writes that shortly before his death Benjamin gave her a copy of the manuscript which contains, however, many variants written in his difficult to decipher handwriting.
Her version of his eighteen Roman numbered paragraphs is included in the book Illuminations. Benjamin thinking is complex thinking. His work is not material for a tea party reading. He loves allusions and even resorts to the supernatural. His hobby after that of book collector—he collected books not to be read but to be possessed—he became a collector of quotes, and aspired to construct a book made up of only quotes.
And he himself left many of his own quotes for posterity … and for writers after him. For purposes of simplification I have extracted chiefly his views on the disaster of Social Democracy. Then we shall clearly realize that it is our task to bring about a real state of emergency, and this will improve our position in the struggle against Fascism.
One reason why Fascism has a chance is that in the name of progress its opponents treat it as a historical norm. To some they will perhaps read like a listing of quotes. For me the Walter benjamin theses on history were far from impromptu or conceived in that last year; they seem to sum up matters he was writing about already in Berlin in his twenties.
They sum up his life. The Benjamin legacy. The class struggle, which is always present to a historian influenced by Marx, is a fight for the crude and material things without which no refined and spiritual things could exist…. They have retroactive force and will constantly call in question every victory, past and present, of the rulers. Historical materialism wishes to retain that image of the past which unexpectedly appears to man singled out by history at a moment of danger ….
That of becoming a tool of the ruling classes. And all rulers are heirs of those who conquered before them. Hence, walter benjamin theses on history, empathy with the victor invariably benefits the rulers. Historical materialists know what that means. Whoever has emerged victorious participates to this day in the triumphal procession in which the present rulers step over those who are lying prostrate.
At the moment when the politicians in whom the opponents of Fascism walter benjamin theses on history placed their hopes are prostrate and confirm their defeat Social Democrats by betraying their own cause, walter benjamin theses on history, these observations are intended to disentangle the political worldlings from the snares in which the traitors have entrapped them.
The conformism which has been part and parcel of Social Democracy from the beginning attaches not only to its political tactics but to its economic views as well, walter benjamin theses on history.
It is one reason for its later breakdown. Nothing has corrupted the German working class so much as the notion that it was moving with the current…. it was but a step to the illusion that the factory work which was supposed to tend toward technological progress constituted a political achievement….
it work, he means already displays the technocratic features later encountered in Fascism…. Not man or men but the struggling, oppressed class itself is the depository of historical knowledge…, walter benjamin theses on history.
This conviction … has always been objectionable to Social Democrats…. Social Democratic theory, and even more its practice, have been formed by a conception of progress which did not adhere to reality but made dogmatic claims…. first of all, the progress of mankind itself….
Secondly, it was something boundless, in keeping with the infinite perfectibility of mankind. Thirdly, progress was regarded as irresistible, something that automatically pursued a straight or spiral course…. History is the subject of a structure whose site is not homogeneous, empty time, but time filled by the presence of the now. This jump, however, takes place in an arena where the ruling class gives the commands….
Walter Benjamin's These on the Philosophy of History
, time: 5:33Walter Benjamin, the Jewish Question and Theses on the Philosophy of History - blogger.com
· Benjamin’s “On the Concept of History”, also known as “Theses on History” and “Theses on the Philosophy of History”, deals with the question of social transformation. This insightful short work is one of Benjamin’s best-known and most cited works. Of all his works, it develops Benjamin’s messianic ideas most completely On the Concept of History Walter Benjamin (often referred to as) Theses on the Philosophy of History 1. I The story is told of an automaton constructed in such a way that it could play a winning game of chess, answering each move of an opponent with a countermove. A puppet in Benjamin completed this essay, sometimes called "On the Concept of History," in the spring of However, it wasn't published until , a decade after Benjamin's death. The essay is divided into 20 extremely brief sections. Benjamin begins the essay with an extended analogy in Section 1
No comments:
Post a Comment